Abstract Objective: High-pressure educational environments, such as the highly competitive university entrance examination, on the one hand, and the undeniable role of self-regulated learning in academic achievement, on the other, underscore the growing need for research in this area. Given the particular importance of tailoring educational interventions to local cultural components, the present study was conducted to compare the effectiveness of two intervention programs, "academic resilience training based on an integrated monotheistic approach" and "mindfulness training", on the self-regulated learning level of female high school students.
Method: This quasi-experimental study utilized a pretest-posttest control group design with two intervention groups and a control group. The target population consisted of female students enrolled in District 10 of Tehran during the 2022–2023 academic year. Participants were selected through convenience sampling, and due to pandemic-related restrictions, the interventions were administered online. The final sample comprised 21 students, allocated to three conditions: academic resilience training (n = 7), mindfulness training (n = 9), and a no-intervention control group (n = 5). Each intervention was conducted over eight 90‑minute online sessions. The Self-Regulated Learning Questionnaire (MSLQ) served as the primary data collection instrument, and the data were analyzed using SPSS (version 25) through analysis of covariance (ANCOVA), followed by LSD post hoc comparisons.
Results: The results of analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) indicated that both training programs significantly increased overall self-regulated learning compared to that in the control group (F=3.681, df=2, p<.05, Partial η²=.473). Both interventions also demonstrated significant effectiveness on the ‘metacognitive strategies’ subscale (F=6.137, df=2, p<.011, Partial η²=.450). However, after controlling for Grade Point Average (GPA), mindfulness training showed significantly greater effectiveness in overall self-regulation (F=4.449, df=1, p<.029, Partial η²=.357) and motivational beliefs (F=4.735, df=1, p<.024, Partial η²=.372), whereas the effect of resilience training on overall self-regulation (p=.125) and motivational beliefs (p=.103) was not statistically significant after controlling for GPA. In the metacognitive strategies component, with GPA controlled, both methods remained significant (F=5.297, df=1, p<.019, Partial η²=.431), and post hoc LSD tests revealed that mindfulness was significantly more effective than resilience in overall self-regulation (p=.012) and metacognitive strategies (p=.015). Neither intervention had a significant effect on "cognitive strategies" (p=.678). Thus, while both approaches are effective in improving self-regulation, mindfulness demonstrates greater effectiveness, particularly when academic achievement is controlled.
Conclusions: Both the integrated monotheistic resilience training and the mindfulness program were effective in improving self-regulated learning. However, the resilience package, as a native intervention grounded in Iranian religious-cultural values, offers unique practical applications within the country's educational system. By utilizing spiritual capacities such as prayer, trust in God, self-awareness, and strengthening the relationship with the Divine, this package not only enhances academic self-regulation but also contributes to reducing test anxiety, increasing hope, and improving students' overall quality of life in the long term. Furthermore, its applicability across diverse learner populations (with low, medium, and high academic achievement) and its compatibility with the cultural context of Iranian schools are among the practical advantages of this approach. These features make it a valuable model for school-based mental health programs, academic counseling, and life skills workshops.