Comparison of the Effect of Conceptual Map and Traditional Instruction on Cognitive Learning Levels in the Course of Thinking and Media Literacy

Document Type: Original Article

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate, Department of Educational Administration, Kazerun Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kazerun, Iran

2 Department of Educational Administration, Kazerun Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kazerun, Iran

3 Department of Educational Administration, Shiraz Branch, Islamic Azad University, Shiraz, Iran

10.22034/iepa.2020.237742.1184

Abstract

This study aimed to compare the effect of using conceptual map and traditional instruction on cognitive learning of Senior high school students in thinking and media literacy course. This is a quasi-experimental research using experimental and control groups. Three classes were chosen randomly (one for conceptual map teaching, one for the combination of lecture-based and conceptual map teaching (combined) and one as the control group).  In the combined group, learners were taught though conceptual mapping while the experimental group was exposed to both teacher-made conceptual map and combined method in eight sessions and the control group experienced traditional instruction. All the three groups completed the teacher-made academic achievement test in both levels of knowledge and high level of thinking.  The validity of the instrument measured through S. H. Lawshe formula was 0.78 and the reliability measured through Kuder - Richardson was 0.807. In order to analyze the data, covariance analysis was used. The findings of this study showed that the instruction was not effective at the level of knowledge, but there was a significant difference in the high level of comprehension which means that the highest effect was observed in the lecturing and conceptual mapping group (combined) while the lowest effect was attributed to the control group. 
Keywords: Presentation and construction of concept map, Bloom cognitive levels, Concept map, Meaningful learning

Keywords


Abbasi, J. (2008). Application of concept maps in high school chemistry education. Master Thesis, Tarbiat Dabir Shahid Rajaei University.
All, C.A., Huycke, L.I., & Fisher, M.J. (2003). Instructional tools for nursing education: An evolving topology. Information and Computation, 208(10), 1169–1192.
Allah Karami, A., & Babamradi, A. (2017). The effect of conceptual teaching method on students' self-regulation and academic self-concept. Educational and School Studies, 6 (1), 105-124.
Amani, V., & Zamani, K. (2019). A review of the use of concept map software in facilitating and improving the quality of chemistry education and learning. Scientific Journal of Research in Chemistry Education, 1(1), 15-34.
Ashuri, J., Kajbaf, M., Seretary, Gh., & Talebi, H. (2014). The effect of educational methods of concept map, participatory and traditional learning on the motivation of academic progress and development of biology course. Research in Curriculum Planning, 2 (14), 63-73.
Bardel, M., & Mahmoudi, F. (2020). Comparison of the effectiveness of concept map and traditional method on students' academic achievement in experimental sciences. New Educational Thoughts, 16 (1), doi: 10.22051 / jontoe.2020.20362.2214
Brandsford, J.D. (2001). How people learn: Brain, mind, experience and school. Washington+D.C: National Academy Press/http:/www.nap.edu.
Chen, C., Huang, C., & Chou, Y. (2019). Effects of augmented reality-based multidimensional concept maps on students’ learning achievement, motivation and acceptance. Univ Access Inf Soc, 18, 257–268. doi:10.1007/s10209-017-0595-z.
Collins, B., & Nyenhuis, R. (2020). The Effectiveness of concept maps for students’ learning and retention. APSA Preprints. doi: 10.33774/apsa-2020-nn3j9.
Fellows, N. J. (1994). A window into Thinking: Using student writing to understand conceptual change in science learning. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 31, 985-1001.
Ghanbari, A. (2015). Investigating the effectiveness of conceptual education training on chemical transplantation concepts in secondary school students. First scientific research conference on strategies for development and promotion of science education in Iran//www.civilica.com/Paper-SCSPSE101-SCSPSE101_016.HTMl
Habok, A. (2008). The construction of concept map by 10 and 13 years old in grammar lessons. Conference of concept mapping. Tallinn, Estonia & Helsiniki, Finland.
Hall, R. H., & O'Donnell, A. M. (1996).Cognitive and affective outcomes of learning from knowledge maps. Contemporary Psychologist, 21, 94-101.
Halvai Kardan, J. (2011). The effect of a concept map on the academic achievement of physics students in the second grade of high school. Master thesis. University of Tabriz. Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology.
Hatami, J., Mirzaei, R., & Abbasi, J. (2009). Improving the quality of teaching chemistry concepts with the help of concept maps. Journal of Educational Technology, 3 (4), 281-296.
Hassanpour, P., & Sheikhzadeh, M. (2018). The Impact of teaching methods based on the concept map on the learning of seventh grade students in work and technology. Research in Curriculum Planning, 2 (30).
Jegede, O.J., & Alaiyemola, F.F. (1990). The effect of concept mapping on student. Journal of Technology and Educational Research, 1(2), 89-100.
Kardan, J., Hatami, J., & Fathi Azar, I. (2016). The effect of concept map on the academic achievement of high school students in physics course, Quarterly Journal of New Educational Approaches, 11(1), 62-41.
Martin, D.J. (1994). Concept mapping as an aid to lesson planning: a longitudinal study. Journal of Elementary Science Education, 6, 11-30.
Mesrabadi, J. (2007). Effects of conceptual map (construction and presentation) and input characteristics of learners on cognitive-emotional effects of biology learning. Ph.D. Thesis. Tabriz University.
Mesrabadi, J., Fathi Azar, A., & Ostvar, N. (2005). Investigating the effectiveness of individual presentation and group construction and conceptual mapping as an educational strategy. Quarterly Journal of Educational Innovation, 13, 13-11.
Mesrabadi, J., Hosseini Nasab, D., & Fatehi, A. (2009). The effect of constructing and presenting a concept map and learning style on memory comprehension and problem solving in biology, Educational and Psychological Studies of Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, 10 (3), 19-15.
Mesrabadi, J., & Ostovar, N. (2009). The effectiveness of a concept map on students' academic achievement in biology, psychology and physics. Journal of Modern Educational Thoughts, 5 (1), 114-93.
Mohammadi, A., Yar Mohammadi Wasel, M., Kurd Noghabi, R., & Jamshidi Moghaddam, M. (2015). The effectiveness of participatory education and individual concept map on students' motivation and academic achievement. Teaching and Learning Technology, 2,139-158
Muijs, D., & Reynolds, D. (2005). Effective teaching: Evidence and practice. London:London.
Novak, J.D., & Canas, A.J. (2008). The Theory underlying concept maps and how to construct and use them. Technical report IHMC Cmaptools. 2006-01 Rev 01-2008, Florida institute for human and machine cognition.
Novak, J.D. (1991). Clarify with concept maps. The Science Teacher, 58 (7), 45-49.
Pia, A., Blasco, E., & Portero, M. J. (2011). Different applications of concept maps in higher education. Journal of Industrial Engineering and Management, 4 (1), 81-102.
Potelle, H., & Rouet, J. (2003). Effects of content representation and readers’ prior knowledge on the comprehension of hypertext. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 58, 327-345. 10.1016/S1071-5819(03)00016-8.
Radfar, A., & Captain, M. (1397). Study of the process of improving self-directed learning indicators by using the concept map technique and collaborative learning in the field of information science and cognition. (Case study: University of Tehran). Library and Information Science Studies, 25 (25), 225-252
Rahmani, A., Abd al-Zadeh, F., Fathi Azar, A., & Mujjal al-Qadam, A. (2005). Comparison of the effect of concept map based education with integrated method on learning the nursing process of students. Education in Medical Sciences, 7 (1), 41-49.
Roth,W., & Roychoudhury, M. (1992).The social construction of scientific concepts or the concept map as conscription device and tool for social thinking in high school. Science      and Education,76, 531-557.
Saif, A. (2015). Modern educational psychology: teaching and learning pedagogy. Seventh edition. Tehran: Doran Publishing.
Sakiyo, J., & Waziri, K. (2015). Concept mapping strategy: An effective tool for improving students’ academic achievement in biology. Journal of Education in Science, Environment and Health (JESEH), 1(1), 56-62.
Sun, Y. (2004). Methods for automated concept mapping between medical database. Journal of Biomedical Informatics, 37, 162-178.
Tsai, C.C. (2000). Relationships between student scientific epistemological beliefs and perceptions of constructivist learning environments. Educational Research, 42,193–205.
Vosoughi, A. (1388). Comparison of the effect of concept map teaching method and traditional teaching method on learning social sciences in pre-university course. Master Thesis, Abhar Islamic University.
Watson, M., & Barrella, E. (2016). Using concept maps to explore the impacts of a learning-cycle-based sustainability module implemented in two institutional contexts. Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice, 142(3),D4016001. 10.1061/(ASCE)EI.1943-5541.0000304.  
Wena, M. L., Tsai, C., Linc, H., & Chuang, S. (2004). Cognitive – metacognitive and content–technical aspect of constructivism internet-based learning environments: A LISREL analysis. Computer & Education, 43(3), 237-248.
Zarei, A. (1397). Assessing the learning rate of eighth year students from quadrilaterals using a concept map.  M.Sc.Thesis, IslamicAzadUniversityof Marvdasht, Faculty of Science, Department of Mathematics.